If this is your first visit, be sure to check out the FAQ by clicking the link above. You may have to register before you can post: click the register link above to proceed. To start viewing messages, select the forum that you want to visit from the selection below. |
|
|
Thread Tools | Display Modes |
#11
|
|||
|
|||
How Children REALLY React To Control
In alt.parenting.spanking Nathan A. Barclay wrote:
: "Chris" wrote in message : ... : In alt.parenting.spanking Nathan A. Barclay wrote: : : : But by and large, the system works. And throwing it out before we're : : positive that we have something that will work better in the real world, : : with real parents and real children, would be foolish. : : Once again, Nathan, you appear to be talking about win/win cooperative : nonpunitive discipline as if it were some sort of new untested concept : rather than a set of approaches to dealing with conflict in the : parent/child relationship developed decades ago and used successfully in : Chris, this is anecdotal evidence. If I argued that there are thousands of : parents who spank and get good results, you would correctly counter that : just because there are thousands of parents who spank and get good results, : that most definitely does not mean that all parents who spank get good : results. So why should I accept the same kind of reasoning from you : regarding non-punitive techniques? : As I keep saying, how well strictly non-punitive techniques work depends on : children's willingness to cooperate. And as I keep saying, you miss the central driving force behind the success of nonpunitive win/win discipline, which is every child's desire for an harmonious relationship with the key adults in their lives (provided the child's needs are being met in the process). You invoke hypothetical children who are completely indifferent to the quality of their relationships with their parents and then you use these hypothetical children to reason that punishment is essential and the lack of it would be a "disaster." But I have never met a child like that and I doubt if you have. True, you have probably seen children who don't seem to care about their parents' feelings, but show me a child like that and I will show you a child whose parent's blow off the child's feelings. Children give back what they get. Chris |
Thread Tools | |
Display Modes | |
|
|
Similar Threads | ||||
Thread | Thread Starter | Forum | Replies | Last Post |
Chemically beating children: Pinellas Poisoners Heilman and Talley | Todd Gastaldo | Pregnancy | 0 | July 4th 04 11:26 PM |
misc.kids FAQ on Breastfeeding Past the First Year | [email protected] | Info and FAQ's | 0 | January 16th 04 09:15 AM |
| | Kids should work... | Kane | Spanking | 12 | December 10th 03 02:30 AM |
| Ray attempts Biblical justification: was U.N. rules Canada should ban spanking | Kane | Spanking | 105 | November 30th 03 05:48 AM |
So much for the claims about Sweden | Kane | Spanking | 10 | November 5th 03 06:31 AM |