A Parenting & kids forum. ParentingBanter.com

If this is your first visit, be sure to check out the FAQ by clicking the link above. You may have to register before you can post: click the register link above to proceed. To start viewing messages, select the forum that you want to visit from the selection below.

Go Back   Home » ParentingBanter.com forum » misc.kids » Pregnancy
Site Map Home Authors List Search Today's Posts Mark Forums Read Web Partners

Birthing Center Closing



 
 
Thread Tools Display Modes
  #1  
Old August 14th 03, 03:28 AM
Vijay
external usenet poster
 
Posts: n/a
Default Birthing Center Closing

Hi All.

I just got a heartbreaking letter from the Elizabeth Seton
Childbearing Center where I gave birth to my daugher Charlotte on
5/20/03. Apparently they can't get anyone to cover them for
malpractice insurance and they are forced to close their doors
September 1st, 2003.

This is the only freestanding birthing center in Manhattan. They
provide high-quality prenatal care, childbirth education classes,
breastfeeding classes, prenatal yoga classes, mommy and me classes,
breastfeeding support groups, sling workshops, baby massage, doulas,
prenatal massage, a lending library of childbirth and parenting books,
and all kinds of other services for the community.

They have 3 amazing birthing rooms with a homey atmosphere with
hardwood floors, regular beds with quilts, kitchinettes, showers, and
big bathtubs that you can give birth in (I did) and a great lounge
area for family members to wait.

It is the most amazing place, I can't even tell you how warm and
friendly and knowledgeable their staff is. Going through my pregnancy
with them was like a dream, and the midwife who attended my labor and
delivery was a pillar of strength and an endless fountain of kind
encouragement. I have met with two different lactation consultants
there, who were both very warm and who really know their stuff.

Is there anything they can do? Does anyone know of any other birthing
centers that faced this sort of situation and somehow remained open?
Does anyone know of any lesser-known insurance companies that might be
willing to cover them? They say they have explored all of their other
options, and none were viable.

I am planning to write to them to ask if there is anything I can do to
help. I also considered writing a letter to be distributed to all
women who are receiving prenatal care there currently to urge them to
consider a home birth attended by one of the Elizabeth Seton midwives.

If anyone has any ideas please let me know.

-V.
  #2  
Old August 14th 03, 04:17 AM
Em
external usenet poster
 
Posts: n/a
Default Birthing Center Closing

"Vijay" wrote in message
snip
Is there anything they can do? Does anyone know of any other birthing
centers that faced this sort of situation and somehow remained open?
Does anyone know of any lesser-known insurance companies that might be
willing to cover them? They say they have explored all of their other
options, and none were viable.

I am planning to write to them to ask if there is anything I can do to
help. I also considered writing a letter to be distributed to all
women who are receiving prenatal care there currently to urge them to
consider a home birth attended by one of the Elizabeth Seton midwives.

If anyone has any ideas please let me know.


The birth center I'm using had a somewhat similar scare this January. They
had to let go of their malpractice insurance, because it was up to 45k per
year and the doctor herself only makes 40k per year. She was going to just
"go bare" and people were going to have to just pay out of pocket if they
wanted to use her or the birth center (she does home births as well and
supervised a nurse-midwife that does home births). As far as I understand
it, doctors are not required to have malpractice insurance--the two problems
with not having it are that health insurance companies won't cover the
services of a non-malpractice insured doctor and if the doctor was to have a
suit brought against her, she would likely be totally wiped out. Anyway, my
doctor went and lobbied at the capital about this, etc.

The resolution was that a coalition of OBs in a large nearby city formed
their own insurance company and she was able to get insurance through them.
I don't how reliable it is or how long it will last, but so far it has kept
her in my "preferred provider" directory. (The birth center itself isn't
"preferred," but people who use it still just pay out-of-network fees for
it, not completely out of pocket). Apparently, this insurance company is a
non-profit corp. and is operated as a "mutual or policyholder owned insurer"
in accordance with laws such in my state--from what I gather they put
all of the premiums into a big fund that they can use to pay any claims with
should they arise. They are officially organized and licensed in my state
and apparently they are good enough for the health insurance companies to
keep covering their doctors.

This group only operates in my state (part of how they can offer insurance
policies affordably), so it unfortunately can't help your birth center, but
I can send you the link to their website if you think it would help at
all--maybe your birth center could join up with a similar sort of effort in
your state? My state is fairly "backward" about lots of things and has been
declared a "crisis state" by the AMA because of its lack of good insurance.
There are lots of OBs who have been basically driven out of business here
and earlier this year many doctors in the state had a massive "white coat
invasion" at the capital where they lobbied and protested for legal change.
Anyway, if the docs here can find a solution that seems to be working for
them, I would imagine that there may be some similar sort of effort in New
York if someone does some digging about it. I really hope so, for your birth
center's sake (and for all of the women who won't get to birth there if they
close)!

HTH a little!

--
Em
edd 9/23/03
(34 weeks)


  #3  
Old August 17th 03, 06:24 AM
Vijay
external usenet poster
 
Posts: n/a
Default Birthing Center Closing UPDATE

Here is the press release from the Elizabeth Seton Web site
(www.birthcenter.org). They are also doing an online petition and
there is information on a letter writing campaign if anyone is
interested.

Press Release: Elizabeth Seton Birthing Center to Close Due to Crisis
in Malpractice Insurance

New York, NY, August 13, 2003 -- The Elizabeth Seton Birthing Center,
which is affiliated with St. Vincent's Hospital Manhattan, announced
this week the closure of the center effective September 1, 2003.
Elizabeth Seton Childbearing Center (ESCbC), formerly the birth center
at the Maternity Center Association -- the first free-standing birth
center in the country -- is being forced to close after almost 30
years of service as a result of the current malpractice insurance
crisis in the United States.

As a result of having no malpractice insurance, ESCbC can no longer
deliver babies at the center as of September 1st, 2003. Letters were
sent to every patient informing them of the closure. The birth center
staff is in the process of making phone calls to all clients to assist
with them with transitioning their care to St. Vincent's Hospital
Manhattan or exploring alternative obstetrical care.

ESCbC was notified by its insurance carrier approximately three weeks
ago that its policy, which expires August 31, 2003, would not be
renewed. After extensive research it was discovered that options
offered by other carriers were either inadequate, required excessive
premiums or unavailable. This situation is not unique to ESCbC and has
been experienced by other birth centers, midwives and obstetricians
throughout the region.

Historically, ESCbC has provided not just prenatal care, but care to
women throughout their life span. The birth center's philosophy is
based on the principle that women have the right to health care that
is safe, fits their lifestyle, and recognizes and respects their
individual, physical, social, spiritual, psychological and economic
needs.

As a free-standing birth center, ESCbC is housed in a space which
includes exam rooms, multi-purpose rooms (for education and community
services) and home-like birthing rooms in a building separate from St.
Vincent's Hospital Manhattan, the affiliate hospital. The birth center
is a not-for-profit corporation organized under New York State law and
sponsored by Saint Vincent's Catholic Medical Centers. It is
responsible for over 400 deliveries annually.

Clinical care at ESCbC is provided by a group of Certified Nurse
Midwives, a Nurse Practitioner and Registered Nurses. Consultants such
as physicians, social workers, lactation consultants and other
alternative care providers enhance the care provided.

The services offered at ESCbC include: well-woman gynecology, prenatal
care, natural childbirth with water-birth option, postpartum care,
childbirth education, and a wide variety of community centered
activities (mother's meetings, support groups, prenatal yoga classes
etc.)

This closure is a situation that is not unique to the Elizabeth Seton
Birthing Center, and has been experienced by other birthing centers in
the city and region due to the escalating costs of malpractice
insurance.

The staff of ESCbC is very proud of the many years of holistic,
respectful and empowering woman's health care that has been provided
in this setting. They are deeply saddened for its clients and feel a
great sense of personal loss.
  #4  
Old August 17th 03, 02:58 PM
Cheryl S.
external usenet poster
 
Posts: n/a
Default Birthing Center Closing UPDATE

Vijay wrote in message
om...
Here is the press release from the Elizabeth Seton
Web site (www.birthcenter.org). They are also doing
an online petition and there is information on a letter
writing campaign if anyone is interested.


I just wanted to express how saddened I am to read this. I saw a birth
at this birth center on A Baby Story once and it did look so wonderful.
I am deeply upset by the power of insurance companies to eliminate
women's choices on how to give birth. I can't understand why a
malpractice insurer wouldn't want to cover birth centers and midwives,
since they are sued less often than OBs and hospitals. It stinks.
--
Cheryl S.
Mom to Julie, 2 yr., 4 mo.
And a boy, EDD 4.Sept

Cleaning the house while your children are small is like
shoveling the sidewalk while it's still snowing.


 




Thread Tools
Display Modes

Posting Rules
You may not post new threads
You may not post replies
You may not post attachments
You may not edit your posts

vB code is On
Smilies are On
[IMG] code is On
HTML code is Off
Forum Jump

Similar Threads
Thread Thread Starter Forum Replies Last Post
Sylvan Learning center to catch up in math/reading? Mark H. General 3 February 25th 04 04:21 PM
MD birth crime: Gastaldo names individual MD... Todd Gastaldo Pregnancy 0 July 29th 03 04:51 PM
Pregnant (Legally Blonde) White House staffers... Todd Gastaldo Pregnancy 0 July 22nd 03 04:36 PM
Suing your OB? (also: ACOG Pres. John M. Gibbons, Jr, MD) Todd Gastaldo Pregnancy 0 July 20th 03 06:27 PM
Chiro orthopedists and global UNREST - and babies... Todd Gastaldo Pregnancy 0 July 13th 03 09:46 PM


All times are GMT +1. The time now is 12:13 AM.


Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.6.4
Copyright ©2000 - 2024, Jelsoft Enterprises Ltd.
Copyright ©2004-2024 ParentingBanter.com.
The comments are property of their posters.